Out of Season — Beth Gibbons & Rustin Man (2002)
The record that waited eight years behind Dummy, and dropped every disguise when it finally arrived.
By Rafi Mercer
There's a particular quiet to a seaside town out of season. The arcades are shuttered and the front is empty. The sea is still there, doing exactly what it did in August, but there's no one left to perform for. What remains is the place as it actually is.
Some records are made like that, after the crowd has gone.
This one began before the crowd arrived. Beth Gibbons had been working with Paul Webb while Portishead were recording Dummy, and then Dummy happened. The Mercury, the imitators and the dinner parties followed, and the other thing was set aside. It stayed set aside through two Portishead albums and a long silence. It finally appeared on 28 October 2002, on Go Beat!, produced by Beth Gibbons and Paul Webb, during the extended intervening period between Portishead's eponymous second studio album Portishead (1997) and appropriately titled Third (2008).

Webb is Rustin Man, and the name is a costume worn lightly. He had been the bassist in Talk Talk, the band that walked away from pop in the late eighties and made Spirit of Eden and Laughing Stock, records built so slowly and with such care for silence that they barely seem to have been built at all. Look at who was in the room for Out of Season and that lineage is everywhere. Lee Harris is on drums. He and Webb attended The Deanes School together, played in the reggae band Eskalator before being recruited to form Talk Talk in 1981, then formed .O.rang together in the early nineties. Phill Brown is credited as engineer on the sessions, the same Phill Brown who engineered those last two Talk Talk albums. From the Bristol side come Adrian Utley and Clive Deamer, along with John Baggott on piano. Nick Ingman conducted and orchestrated the strings.
Two bands' worth of patience, gathered round one voice.
AllMusic lists three places of work: Konk Studios, Sanctuary Westside, and The Barn, Devon. That last one matters. You can hear a record that wasn't made entirely in a city.
The first sound isn't a voice. On Mysteries, the first sound one hears is a rising gust of wind. Then an acoustic guitar, and then Gibbons, singing with nothing at all to hide behind.
That's what Out of Season gives you. On Dummy her voice was the one live thing in a room of manufactured age: scratched vinyl, borrowed strings, beats sampled off the floor. Here nothing is forged. The guitars are guitars. The brass, the accordion and the piano are played by people sitting near each other. Gibbons plays acoustic guitar herself, and the vocoder that turns up is a texture rather than a trick. All the scaffolding that made Portishead sound like a film from a future that never came has been taken away. What's left is the singer as she actually is.
She doesn't fill the space. She waits in it.
Critics went looking for her ancestors. Slant heard influences from folk (Nick Drake, Joni Mitchell) to jazz (Ella Fitzgerald, Nina Simone), and others reached for Billie Holiday and Dusty Springfield. The names are right, but they miss what's strange about it. This isn't pastiche. It sounds less like a woman paying tribute to old records than like one who has walked into the same weather they came from. Tom the Model carries brass like something half-remembered from a Sunday afternoon, and more than one reviewer noticed how close it comes to Spirit of Eden. Romance and Drake move so slowly they seem to be listening to themselves. Webb's arrangements leave long gaps open, and Gibbons crosses each one carefully, as if the floor might not hold.
That's the Talk Talk inheritance, put to a different use. Silence here isn't atmosphere. It's where the record keeps its feeling.
Heard whole, the ten tracks run 43:46, and they behave less like a set of songs than like one long weather system. The wind that opens Mysteries never quite settles. The record leaves us the way it came in, with the slow-burning "Rustin Man", Webb's alias turned into a closing song as though he'd only been signing the register.
Then it vanished. It went out of print shortly after, making this a sought after rarity, and for a long time it was the record people mentioned rather than played. In 2019 it was remastered at Abbey Road and pressed on heavyweight vinyl through Island/UMC, and it entered the British charts at number 24, seventeen years after it first came out. Mysteries had a quieter life in between, turning up in Cédric Klapisch's Les Poupées Russes and in Wim Wenders' Palermo Shooting. Some records find their audience on release. This one found it by staying put until people came looking.
That's why it belongs beside Dummy in this month's Listening Session. Played one after the other, the two records make a single argument. The first is a voice inside a beautiful forgery. The second is the same voice after the forgery has been taken down, singing in a room where everything is exactly what it seems.
Eight years apart. Begun in the same months.
Dummy was walked across a studio floor until it sounded old. Out of Season never needed to be. It was simply left alone until its time came round.
Who is Rustin Man?
Rustin Man is the pseudonym of Paul Webb, Talk Talk's bassist. He co-wrote and co-produced Out of Season with Beth Gibbons, and in 2019 he released his own album as Rustin Man, Drift Code.
How does Out of Season differ from Portishead?
There are no samples, no breakbeats and no manufactured vinyl crackle. It's an acoustic record of folk and jazz played by musicians from both Talk Talk's and Portishead's circles, which leaves Gibbons' voice almost completely exposed.
Is Out of Season available on vinyl?
Yes. The original pressing went out of print soon after release, but the album was remastered at Abbey Road and reissued on heavyweight vinyl in 2019, when it reached number 24 in the UK chart.
I'm Rafi Mercer. If you'd like more records like this, subscribe. To keep reading, browse The Listening Shelf.